01
Are Lightroom presets actually worth buying, or is it a scam?
Most of them are not worth it, and the Reddit skepticism is earned. A $5 pack of 300 presets is 300 sliders somebody moved once. They are built to look good on the seller's sample photos and fall apart on yours.
The ones worth paying for do one job: they get you to a photographer's starting point in one click, so you spend your time on the last 20 percent instead of the first 80. That is what a preset is for. It is a base, not a finished edit. If a pack promises a finished edit in one click, that is the tell.